Welcome to Sugar N’ Spice
At Sugar N' Spice, we believe in crafting wholesome, homemade comfort food that warms the heart. Nestled in a historic building in Waterford, PA, our restaurant offers an inviting atmosphere where patrons enjoy generous portions of American cuisine. Each dish is prepared on-site, from savory meatloaf to delectable homemade desserts, echoing cherished family recipes. Our friendly staff strives to provide attentive service, creating a community dining experience. With a charming decor that reflects the spirit of yesteryear, Sugar N' Spice is not just a meal; it's a delightful journey through culinary nostalgia, inviting locals and travelers alike to savor every bite.
-
32 High St, Waterford, PA 16441 Hotline: (814) 796-0060
Welcome to Sugar N’ Spice, a culinary gem nestled in the beautiful town of Waterford, PA. Located at 32 High St, this charming establishment not only serves comfort food but does so in a way that brings back feelings of nostalgia and warmth. Known for its home-cooked style American dishes, Sugar N' Spice is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience filled with flavors that remind you of your grandma’s kitchen.
As soon as you enter, you’re greeted by an ambiance that radiates charm. The restaurant resides in a historic building, echoing the rich history of the 19th century. With each room adorned with antique decor and quilts, Sugar N' Spice transports you back in time while providing a cozy spot to enjoy your meal. Customers rave about the friendly and attentive service, with staff members, like Yvette, becoming an integral part of your dining experience by providing cheerful suggestions and ensuring timely service.
- Freshly Prepared Meals: Every dish at Sugar N' Spice is made to order. Customer reviews consistently highlight the freshness of ingredients—right down to the mashed potatoes—prepared on-site to achieve an authentic home-cooked taste.
- Generous Portions: Expect hefty servings that will leave your appetite more than satisfied. Many patrons, like Dennis M. and C.T. C., mention the value for money, often taking home leftovers because the portions are so generous.
- A Menu for Everyone: From Amish-style dishes to American classics, the menu covers a vast array of mouthwatering options. Whether you're in the mood for a flavorful French Dip, savory meatloaf, or creamy chicken with biscuits, there's something for every palate.
- Irresistible Desserts: Sugar N’ Spice also makes a name for itself with homemade desserts that call to you from the moment you walk in. Be sure to indulge in one of their delicious pies or brownies; they are a perfect way to end your meal.
- Support Local: Dining at Sugar N’ Spice isn’t just about the food; it’s about supporting the local community. As Gina B. points out, it’s a great way to enjoy comfort food while supporting a local business.
Many guests return again and again, drawn by the delightful meals that feel as if they’ve come straight from family recipes. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be prepared for a dining experience that combines history, charm, and incredible flavors. So next time you’re in the area, don’t miss the opportunity to savor the offerings of Sugar N’ Spice. You might just find yourself bringing home a piece of their heartfelt hospitality—and maybe a dessert or two!
For reservations or inquiries, you can reach Sugar N’ Spice at (814) 796-0060. Come savor a slice of comfort food history!
All of the food is prepared on sight even the mashed potatoes. Everything is good I have not gotten a bad meal. I usually have to take a box home with me. Ps the deserts are home made also.
Good sized portions, comfy atmosphere, great comfort food! A nice place to dine while also supporting the local area!
Great ambiance, and great food. The service is very attentive and very friendly. It's like having homemade comfort food
My wife & I dined at Sugar 'n Spice for the first time on Sat., 09.10.2022. Arriving around 7:00 p.m., we had to wait to be seated for a few minutes but not for an unreasonable amount of time given the day & time. Once seated, we were served by Yvette who did an outstanding job! She was cheerful, made great suggestions, timely in all aspects of service, & was a great representative of the business by always speaking well of how things were prepared & handled by the staff. The food was excellent. My sampler included meatloaf, ham, & a boneless pork chop. All portions were extremely generous & I feel one would be hard pressed to find a better value for the price of our meals. I was disappointed that the dinner rolls were not homemade but they were still good. While Sugar 'n Spice IS located in a historic building, it's my opinion the decor is far from adequate in conveying without necessarily having to imitate an early 1800s atmosphere. Early 20th century 'grandma' is not the look I would choose & a deep cleaning would bring about substantial improvement. Such changes would easily bump my rating to 5-stars. A hour of travel for a solid dining experience is something my wife & I are willing to do. I will now add Sugar 'n Spice to our list of worthwhile options. May your experience be every bit as pleasant as ours! ------------ Hey, fellow Yelpers! If you've read to this point, please take a moment to rate my review as it helps keep me motivated. Thank you!
In an easy to access area, offering a rather large menu and scrumptious meals. The Atmosphere here is very charming.
French Dip for the win! If I could end my review with that I would because it honestly was very good, but I should start at the beginning. My cousin took my mother and me here for lunch. Parking was easy to find as there is a sizable lot behind the restaurant. The restaurant appears to be in a very old building converted from something else - a hotel by chance? - and the door handle amusedly gave us some troubles getting in. We were quickly seated in a room that had quilts covering every surface. It appears there was a roof leak at one point as a couple of the quilts on the ceiling had water damage. The table density was a bit tight for my liking as I barely could squeeze in and I am a fairly small person. They sat us beside the only other occupied table but that table started longer than we did so there was no banging of chairs. All that was quickly forgotten when the food came out. The portion sizes were huge! Now while I can't say the fries were notable - they were good but just not notable - the French Dip was incredible. Soft squishy bread, thinly sliced but stacked high pieces of deliciously cooked meat, a bit of cheese, and au jus enough for the sandwich and fries! The water even was good, which was something of note the more I ate in the area. They shut down all of January and February so if you're reading this know you may have to wait! But it is well worth it!
An amazing historical place in rural Pennsylvania serving Amish style dishes. I went there for lunch on a beautiful Wednesday afternoon. The place was filled with locals, mostly old families. The internet looks so beautiful and culturally- rich. It's a time machine taking you to the 19th century in an old place once visited and stayed in by the 12th president of the United States. The service was nice and timely. I was seated immediately at a beautiful table in one of the rooms with a lot of cultural and historical vibe . I ordered the soup of the day (ham and beans) and one of the dishes of the day ( creamy chicken with biscuits). The food was so tasty. The portion was huge and I didn't have room for dessert but how I could forgo tasting Amish-style pies? I ordered a whole pie to take out and have with my family tonight. I enjoyed my visit and meal and I will certainly come to this place again in the future and recommend it to my lovely Yelp audience.
This is one of our favorite places to eat! Whether it's breakfast, lunch or dinner, you won't be disappointed. Huge portions, friendly staff and charming decor. Every room is decorated with historic pieces that give you a sense of life years ago. We have tried almost everything on the menu and love it all. The food reminds me of old family recipes. The second floor of this historic building has a gift shop with many handmade items and rooms set up as they were back in the 1800's. Whether you are traveling through this quaint town or live local, I suggest you stop in for a dish of your favorite home style comfort food.